This is a transcript of Stop Physician Burnout PODCAST # 123
In America, it’s been two weeks since Luigi Mangione was arrested for the murder of Brian Thompson, CEO of a major U.S. health insurance company. The public reaction to this murder and arrest has made it abundantly clear that the American people understand the hypocrisy at the heart of healthcare.
This has direct implications for you, as a leader in the healthcare industry. In this episode, you'll learn how to stay on the right side of ethics and karma. You’ll discover how to be seen as a good leader, a shining light amidst the dysfunction of U.S. healthcare.
Public Reaction and Industry Disgust
In this episode, I’ll share some signs of public support for the murder and widespread disgust with the insurance industry. You’ll see just how many areas of U.S. healthcare are plagued by hypocrisy and conflicts of interest. I’ll also give you a "secret agent decoder" to recognize when leadership conversations are veering into unethical territory.
This awareness will help ensure you work in a segment of the industry where, if people talk about you, they recognize you as one of the good guys. No one should ever think you deserve to be "rubbed out" for the greater good.
Moral Injury and Insurance Companies
As physicians, you and I both know why we dislike health insurance companies. They often prevent us from providing the care we know our patients need. This is a major source of moral injury—the distress caused when you’re unable to do the right thing due to systemic barriers like:
- Denials of Authorization: Blocking necessary treatments.
- Denials of Payment: Refusing to pay for services already provided.
But I always thought the general public wasn’t as aware of these issues as doctors are. Recent internet reactions have shown otherwise.
The Internet’s Response to the CEO’s Death
When Brian Thompson's employer published a eulogy, it received 90,000 laughing emojis. Social media was filled with posts like:
- “Free Luigi!”
- “Leave a bottle of water and some cookies by your back door—he’s on the run.”
- “I’d like to have empathy for a healthcare CEO being removed from the planet, but I haven’t received the proper authorization.”
Even the mainstream press described the American healthcare industry as “legendarily monstrous.” Popular commentator Joe Rogan called the healthcare industry “effing gross.”
These reactions show that while doctors experience professional abuse from insurance companies, the general public experiences personal abuse. Lives are lost due to rejected pre-authorizations, and bankruptcies result from denied claims.
The Role of Health Insurance: Does It Serve Healthcare?
Healthcare is meant to diagnose and treat disease and ease suffering. But what role do private health insurance companies play in this mission?
Certainly, some segments of the industry help distribute healthcare funds. But United Healthcare, where Brian Thompson worked, rejects 32% of claims—double the industry average. They justify this with terms like “inappropriate utilization,” but the real-world consequences are devastating.
Every rejected claim adds to the company's bottom line, creating a conflict of interest between profit and patient well-being.
The Dichotomy of Leadership and Public Perception
This tragedy highlights a stark dichotomy: You can be a good leader in a successful business, but if that business harms people, public perception will be harsh.
Brian Thompson was described as a great guy and family man, yet the public saw him as a symbol of an evil industry. The lesson? Your leadership quality is judged not just by your skills, but by the ethics of your industry.
How to Avoid Being Seen as "Evil"
Ask yourself: Is what you do consistent with the mission of healthcare—diagnosing disease and easing suffering? Or are you working in a business model that prioritizes profits over people?
The core polarity in healthcare is Profit vs. People:
- Profit: Financial gains and organizational income.
- People: Patients who need care and providers who deliver it.
When profit dominates decisions, it corrupts the system. United Healthcare’s business model—with its 32% rejection rate—clearly prioritizes profit over people.
Recognizing When You’ve Crossed the Ethical Line
As a leader, you need to recognize when conversations veer into unethical territory. Here’s your secret agent decoder:
- Notice when discussions shift from balancing profit and people to focusing solely on profit.
- If no one in the room is considering the impact on patients or providers, you need to speak up.
According to the Quadruple Aim, healthcare leaders must advocate for:
- Patients: Quality care, timely and cost-effective.
- Providers: Supportive systems and a healthy workplace culture.
A Real-World Example of Ethical Awareness
I recently spoke to a young woman working for a health tech startup. She was programming AI algorithms for a company that denied claims for pre-authorizations and payments.
She thought she was just doing her job. But when I asked her to consider the ethical impact of her work, she gasped and said, “Oh, I never looked at it that way.”
This is the kind of ethical awareness every healthcare leader needs.
Balancing Profit and People in the C-Suite
If you’re in the C-suite—a CMO, Chief Wellness Officer, or other executive role—you’ve likely noticed when discussions shift into money-only territory.
When that happens, represent the people:
- Patients who need care.
- Providers who deliver that care.
Profit is necessary to keep the business afloat, but it should never be the sole outcome. In healthcare, we must balance financial performance with ethical care delivery.
Final Thoughts: Karma and Your Legacy
Karma doesn’t distinguish between your leadership quality and your organization’s impact. If your industry is corrupt, no amount of skill can save your reputation.
Ask yourself: “Is this how I want to go out?” The recent events have shown that the public knows who the bad actors are in healthcare. You don’t want to be the target of that outrage.
What’s Next
In the next episode, I’ll show you how to balance profit and people in the C-suite and what to say when conversations tip into profit-only territory.
If you realize you’re working in a corrupt business model, it’s not too late to get out. Make sure you stay on the right side of ethics and karma.
That’s it for today’s episode of the Stop Physician Burnout Podcast. Subscribe, leave a review, and until next time, keep breathing and have a great day!
~~~~~~~~~~
PLEASE LEAVE A COMMENT:
How can you tell when your leadership conversations tip over the line into evil territory?